This post is for veterans, service members, and surviving spouses under contract on a home with a VA loan. It explains VA's published rules in plain words. Your lender and your purchase contract decide how they apply to your deal.
Why the appraisal lists repairs
VA sets Minimum Property Requirements, or MPRs, so that a home is safe, structurally sound, and sanitary. Chapter 12 of the VA Lenders Handbook says a property must meet them before VA will guarantee the loan.
When the appraiser sees something that does not appear to meet MPRs, the appraisal is done "subject to" the repair. The value in the report assumes the work is finished. The appraiser is told to call for repairs, not for further inspections, and to leave out cosmetic items and normal wear and tear.
Those repair items carry over to the Notice of Value, the document VA issues with the appraised value. Our VA minimum property requirements buyer list covers what the appraiser looks for in the first place.
Who pays for the repairs
The MPR chapter of the handbook says what has to be fixed and by when. It does not assign the cost to the buyer or the seller. In practice, that is a term you and the seller work out in the purchase contract, with help from your agent.
The usual paths look like this:
- The seller does the work before closing. Buyers can ask for this, since the seller still owns the house.
- The buyer pays for the work. Ask your lender first how it handles buyer-paid repairs, including when work can start and what paperwork it needs.
- The price or terms change. Some buyers and sellers rework the price or the contract so the repair cost makes sense for both sides.
Get the answer in writing before any contractor starts. Until closing, the seller owns the property, so a buyer paying for work on someone else's house should have the agreement and the lender's sign-off in hand.
How the repairs get cleared
A repair on the Notice of Value is a condition on the loan. The work has to be finished, or handled through escrow as described below, before VA will guarantee the loan, so your lender will need to confirm it. Ask early what proof it accepts.
Some items carry their own rules. For a home built before 1978, the handbook presumes lead-based paint, treats peeling or chipping paint as a safety repair, and says the VA-assigned appraiser must certify that those repairs are complete.
Escrow for work after closing
Some repairs can wait until after closing. The handbook says lenders may hold funds in escrow for repairs finished after the loan closes. It also says all repairs must be done, and the escrowed funds paid out, before VA will guarantee the loan.
The handbook says that, depending on the work, finishing it after closing may be to the veteran's advantage. Whether your lender offers this, and for which kinds of work, is up to the lender. Our post on repair escrow holdbacks walks through the questions to ask.
Asking VA to waive a repair
After the Notice of Value is issued, a veteran can ask VA to consider waiving an MPR repair. Per the handbook, three things must be true:
- The veteran signs the request.
- The lender agrees with it.
- The home is still habitable from a safety, structural soundness, and sanitation standpoint.
VA says these requests should not be used to waive repairs that could leave a safety problem. An inspection report from a licensed professional is not required, but the handbook notes it helps the veteran understand the item.
A waiver can change the numbers. Since the appraisal assumed the repair was done, VA may lower the value by what that repair would have added. That matters because of 38 CFR 36.4339. For a purchase, the loan generally can't exceed the reasonable value, and the veteran certifies that any amount of the price above that value was paid in cash from their own funds. Talk with your lender before you file a waiver so you know how a lower value would affect your cash to close.
What to ask your lender and agent
- Which items on my Notice of Value are repair conditions?
- Do you allow buyer-paid repairs, and when can the work start?
- What proof of completion do you need for each item?
- Do you offer an escrow holdback for any of these repairs?
- If I ask VA to waive an item, how could a lower value change my cash to close?
- Does my contract say who pays for VA-required repairs, and what happens if nobody agrees?
FAQ
Does the seller have to pay for VA appraisal repairs?
The MPR chapter of the VA handbook does not say the seller must pay. Who pays is usually settled in the purchase contract between buyer and seller.
Can I close before the repairs are done?
Sometimes. A lender may let you close with funds held in escrow for the work, but every repair must be finished and the escrow paid out before VA guarantees the loan. Lenders differ on whether they offer this.
Will a waiver always lower the value?
No. If the repair adds little value, the handbook says VA may issue the Notice of Value without a change in value. If it does add value, VA may reduce the value by that amount.
Is a repair list a sign the house is a bad buy?
Not by itself. It means the appraiser saw items that affect safety, soundness, or sanitation and that need to be fixed or waived. A home inspection, which the Notice of Value recommends, gives you a fuller picture.
One thing to do
Pull out your purchase contract today and find the line on repairs. If it does not say who pays for VA-required repairs, ask your agent about it before the appraisal comes back. If you want help reading a repair list on a VA loan, get in touch here.
Disclaimer: Jeff Shin, Mortgage Loan Originator, NMLS #1041652. Chicago. Equal Housing Lender. Not a commitment to lend.
Sources: VA Pamphlet 26-7, Lenders Handbook, Chapter 12, Minimum Property Requirements (effective for appraisals ordered after May 1, 2026), Topics 1, 32, and 43; 38 CFR 36.4339, Eligibility of loans; reasonable value requirements; BankPricer, "VA minimum property requirements: a buyer list"; BankPricer, "Repair escrow holdback checks before closing".