Jeff Shin
NMLS #1041652 · Barrett Financial Group, L.L.C. NMLS #181106
Call

Loan Products ยท Talk First

Self-employed income: when this year is lower than last

Your business had a strong year, then a slower one. Now you want to buy or refinance, and the most recent tax return shows less income than the one before it. A lower year does not end the conversation, but it changes how a lender does the math and what it asks you to show.

This post covers one situation: you have at least two years of self-employment, and the newer year is lower. If you are still working out whether you have enough history at all, our post on the two-year self-employment rule and its exceptions covers that first. If you are about to write an offer, the declining income checks before you make an offer post is the shorter pre-offer list. This is general information, not tax advice and not a commitment to lend. The lender makes the final call on your file.

Why the lender looks at two years side by side

A lender wants to know whether your income will keep coming. The HUD Handbook 4000.1, which sets FHA rules, says income from businesses with annual earnings that are stable or increasing is acceptable. A drop between years is the thing that triggers a closer look.

The conventional guide from Fannie Mae, Selling Guide B3-3.5-01 says the same idea in its own terms. Before approving a self-employed borrower, the lender must analyze the stability of the income, the demand for what the business sells, the financial strength of the business, and whether the business can keep producing enough income for the borrower to make the payments on the new loan.

So two years of returns are a trend line, and the direction of that line matters as much as the totals.

How FHA counts a lower year

The FHA handbook spells out the math. The lender calculates gross self-employment income using the lesser of two numbers:

  • the average over the previous two years, or
  • the average over the previous one year.

In practice, if the newer year is lower, the one-year figure is the smaller one, and that is the number the lender uses. A strong earlier year does not lift the result back up.

The handbook also draws a line on how big the drop can be. If business income declines by more than the limit the handbook sets over the analysis period, a file run through FHA's automated scorecard must be downgraded to manual underwriting. Under the manual underwriting section, the lender then has to document that the business income is now stable.

That section gives one path for a larger drop. The lender may treat the income as stable if it can document that an extenuating circumstance caused the reduction, you can show the income has been stable or increasing for at least 12 months since, and you qualify using the reduced income. The exact threshold and wording are in the handbook, and your lender will apply it to your returns.

How a conventional loan reads a lower year

The conventional guide does not use a single fixed formula in the same way. It requires the lender to prepare a written analysis of your personal income, including business income or loss, to find the amount of stable and continuous income that will be available to you.

For a business owner, that analysis is meant to:

  • consider whether the business income recurs,
  • measure year-to-year trends for gross income, expenses, and taxable income,
  • figure out what share of gross income went to expenses and what share became taxable income, and
  • set a trend for the business based on how those shares changed over time.

The lender can use the comparative income analysis form, the guide's income calculator, or another method that reaches a comparable conclusion. Either way, the written analysis stays in the loan file.

The guide's general income section, B3-3.1-01 adds the baseline test for any income: the lender must document that it is stable, has a history of receipt, and is reasonably expected to continue. These sections do not treat a lower year as an automatic no. The lender has to explain, in writing, why the income it uses is likely to continue, and a falling trend makes that harder to support at the higher figure.

Is "this year" a filed return or year-to-date?

People mean two different things when they say this year is lower, and lenders treat them differently.

If the lower year is already on a filed tax return, it is part of the two years the lender reviews, and the calculations above apply to it directly.

If the lower year is the current one and has not been filed yet, the lender may still see it. The FHA handbook requires a year-to-date profit and loss statement and a balance sheet when more than a calendar quarter has passed since the end of the most recent tax year. A balance sheet is not required for borrowers who file Schedule C. A soft current year can show up in that statement even when both filed returns look fine.

In either case, expect questions. Ask your lender early which version of this year it will be looking at.

What to gather before you apply

Being ready for the lender's questions saves time later. Before you apply:

  • Have both years of signed personal returns, and business returns if you file them, with every schedule attached.
  • If the current year is more than a quarter along, have a year-to-date profit and loss statement ready, plus a balance sheet if your business type needs one.
  • Write a short, plain explanation of why the income dropped. A lost client, a one-time project ending, time off for a health or family reason, or a planned change in how the business runs are all different stories, and the lender needs to know which one it is.
  • If income has come back since the drop, gather what shows it, such as recent monthly statements that line up with your profit and loss.
  • List any business debt you personally guarantee, and ask your lender how it will count that debt in your file.

Leave the tax questions to your tax preparer. A mortgage review works from the returns as filed.

Questions to ask your loan officer

  • Which year's income are you using, and how did you get that number?
  • Does the drop on my returns change how my file is underwritten?
  • Will you need a year-to-date profit and loss statement or balance sheet, and from when?
  • If the lower figure controls, what price range still works for me?

Asking for the calculation in writing is reasonable. It tells you what the lender actually sees.

FAQ

Will one bad year stop me from getting a mortgage?

Not necessarily. Under FHA rules, a lower year usually means the lower average is the one used. A bigger drop adds steps, such as manual underwriting and proof that income is stable again. Under the conventional guide, the lender has to support in writing why the income it uses will continue.

Can the lender just use my better year?

Generally no. Both guides look at the trend across years rather than the best single year, and the FHA calculation uses the lesser of the two averages.

What if the drop was from a one-time event?

Tell the lender up front and document it. Under the FHA manual underwriting section, a documented extenuating circumstance plus at least 12 months of stable or rising income since then is one way a larger drop can still be treated as stable.

One thing to do

Put your last two years of returns next to each other and note where the newer year is lower and why, in one or two sentences. If you want someone to look at how a lender would read those two years before you apply, send a short note through Get In Touch.

Disclaimer: Jeff Shin, Mortgage Loan Originator, NMLS #1041652. Chicago. Equal Housing Lender. Not a commitment to lend.

Sources: HUD Handbook 4000.1, II.A.4.c.x Self-Employment Income (TOTAL), II.A.5 Self-Employment Income (Manual), and TOTAL downgrade criteria (last revised 8/12/2026); Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.5-01, Underwriting Factors and Documentation for a Self-Employed Borrower; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.1-01, General Income Information.