This post is about the monthly mortgage insurance premium, or MIP, on an FHA loan for a home you already own. It is general information, not a commitment to lend, and your servicer or a lender makes the final call on your file. If you have a conventional loan with private mortgage insurance instead, our post on removing PMI when you're self-employed covers that side.
FHA insurance does not come off like PMI
With a conventional loan, private mortgage insurance can be cancelled once you reach certain points on the payment schedule. FHA works differently. According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, mortgage insurance is required on all FHA loans, and it comes in two parts: an upfront cost at closing and a monthly cost in your payment.
That has one practical result. Paying down an FHA loan, or watching your home's value climb, does not by itself end the monthly premium. The end date was set when the loan was made.
Step 1: Find out how long your MIP lasts
For loans with an FHA case number assigned on or after June 3, 2013, the rules come from HUD Mortgagee Letter 2013-04. Two things decide how long you pay:
- Your loan-to-value at closing, meaning the loan amount (before any financed upfront premium) compared with the lower of the price or the appraised value.
- Your loan term.
Under that letter, loans that started in the lower loan-to-value group pay the monthly premium for the first 11 years or until the loan ends, whichever comes first. Loans that started in the higher group, which is where a small down payment puts you, pay it until the end of the loan term. The letter lists the exact cutoff between the two groups.
Loans with case numbers assigned before June 3, 2013 followed older cancellation rules, so if you bought before then, ask your servicer which rule applies to you.
How to check yours: pull your closing disclosure and note the loan amount, the price, and the closing date. Then call your servicer and ask two questions. When is the final monthly MIP payment scheduled? Is my loan in the 11-year group or the loan-term group?
If you are in the 11-year group and close to the end, waiting may be the simplest route. If your MIP runs for the life of the loan, the only way to stop paying it is to move out of the FHA loan, usually by refinancing into a conventional loan or by selling.
Step 2: Check your equity for a conventional loan
A switch only helps if the new conventional loan does not come with its own mortgage insurance. The conventional loan guide from Fannie Mae, Selling Guide B7-1-01 says a lender must get mortgage insurance on a conventional first mortgage when the loan-to-value is above a set limit. If your equity is under that line, you would trade FHA insurance for private mortgage insurance, which can be cancelled later but still adds to the payment for now.
To estimate where you stand:
- Ask your servicer for a payoff quote. The balance on your statement can differ from it.
- Look at recent sales of similar homes nearby for a rough sense of value. A lender will order its own valuation, and that number is the one that counts.
- If you plan to roll closing costs into the new loan, add them to the balance, since a bigger loan means less equity on paper.
If the numbers are close, ask a loan officer to run it both ways: no new mortgage insurance, and new private mortgage insurance that can later come off.
Step 3: Check your credit before you apply
A refinance is a new loan, so the lender reviews your file again. Under the guide's credit score requirements, the lender orders a new credit report for each borrower. Your score today, not your score when you bought, is what the new loan uses.
Before you apply:
- Pull your credit reports and dispute anything wrong.
- Keep card balances low in the months before you apply.
- Hold off on opening new accounts or financing a large purchase.
- Stay current on every payment, including the FHA loan you are trying to leave.
If your credit has slipped since you bought, a conventional loan may not price well enough to beat what you have, even after the MIP goes away. That is worth knowing before you pay for an appraisal.
Step 4: If you're self-employed, line up income documents
The new loan also gets a new income review. For self-employed borrowers, the conventional guide's self-employed section generally calls for signed personal and business tax returns, or IRS transcripts, for the most recent two years.
That matters if your business had a rough year since you bought. The lender works from the income on those returns, so a lower year can change what you qualify for. If you want the full picture of what an underwriter asks for, see our self-employed underwriting documents checklist and the post on the two-year self-employment rule and its exceptions.
Step 5: Weigh how long you plan to stay
Dropping MIP is a monthly saving, and a refinance has upfront costs. The longer you plan to stay in the home, the more months you have to make those costs back.
Ask the lender for a Loan Estimate. The CFPB's Loan Estimate page explains how to read each section, including the closing costs. Then compare three things side by side:
- Your current payment, with the MIP included.
- The new payment, with any private mortgage insurance included.
- The total cost to close the new loan.
The refinance break-even calculator shows how many months it takes for the monthly difference to cover the closing costs. If you expect to sell or move before that point, the switch may cost more than it saves. Our post on refinance break-even months walks through the math in more detail.
Also look at the rate on your current loan. If it is low compared with what you would get today, dropping the MIP may not make up for a higher rate on the new loan. Compare the full payments side by side.
Why an FHA Streamline does not drop MIP
An FHA Streamline refinance can lower your payment in some cases, but it keeps you in an FHA loan, and FHA loans carry mortgage insurance. If your goal is to stop paying MIP, a streamline is not the tool. If your goal is a lower payment and you want to stay with FHA, our FHA Streamline checks post covers what to look at.
Quick checklist
- Closing disclosure in hand: loan amount, price, closing date.
- Servicer call: final MIP date and which duration group you are in.
- Payoff balance and a rough value estimate.
- Credit reports pulled and errors disputed.
- Two years of tax returns ready if you are self-employed.
- Loan Estimate compared against your current payment.
- Break-even months compared against how long you plan to stay.
FAQ
Can I ask my servicer to remove FHA mortgage insurance?
Generally no, not in the way you can ask to cancel conventional PMI. FHA MIP runs for the period set when the loan was made. To end it sooner, you usually need to leave the FHA loan by refinancing or selling.
Does a higher home value help?
It can help a switch. A higher value means more equity, which can keep a new conventional loan from needing its own mortgage insurance. It does not shorten MIP on the FHA loan you have now.
Will I pay mortgage insurance on the new loan?
Maybe. It depends on how much equity you have when the new loan closes. If you do need it, conventional private mortgage insurance can be cancelled later under its own rules.
One thing to do
Call your servicer this week and ask for the final monthly MIP payment date on your loan. If it runs for the life of the loan and you want someone to look at whether a switch makes sense, send a short note through Get In Touch.
Disclaimer: Jeff Shin, Mortgage Loan Originator, NMLS #1041652. Chicago. Equal Housing Lender. Not a commitment to lend.
Sources: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What is mortgage insurance and how does it work?; HUD Mortgagee Letter 2013-04, Revision of FHA policies concerning cancellation of the annual MIP; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B7-1-01, Provision of Mortgage Insurance; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-5.1-01, General Requirements for Credit Scores; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.5-01, Underwriting Factors and Documentation for a Self-Employed Borrower; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Loan Estimate explainer.